When MIT and Yale announced they were going back to requiring test scores, headlines suggested that test-optional was over. It is not. Here is what actually changed, what did not, and how to make the right decision for your student's specific list.
What actually happened
A small group of highly selective private universities reversed their test-optional policies and went back to requiring SAT or ACT scores. The list includes MIT, Yale, Dartmouth, Harvard, Brown, and a handful of others. These are real changes that affect students applying to those specific schools.
What they do not represent: a broad shift in higher education. More than 80 percent of four-year colleges in the United States remain test-optional as of 2026. The University of California system is permanently test-blind and will not look at scores under any circumstances. The CSU system is test-free for admission. The colleges that made headlines represent a narrow, specific tier of highly selective institutions, most of which accept fewer than 15 percent of applicants.
The three categories, defined
When to submit scores at a test-optional school
The decision rule is straightforward. Look up the middle 50% score range for admitted students at each test-optional school on your list. This is the range between the 25th and 75th percentile of enrolled students, and most colleges publish it.
Score is at or above the 75th percentile for that school. A strong score is a clear positive signal.
Score falls in the middle range (25th to 75th percentile). Whether to submit depends on the rest of the application. If grades, activities, and essays are strong, submitting may add modest support. If other parts of the application are the stronger story, it may not be worth including.
Score is below the 25th percentile. Submitting draws attention to a weak data point without adding anything positive.
Why some colleges went back to test-required
The colleges that reverted, MIT, Yale, Dartmouth, Harvard, and others, cite internal research suggesting that standardized test scores, combined with other application materials, improve their ability to identify high-potential students from under-resourced backgrounds where grade inflation or limited course offerings make GPA a less reliable signal.
This is a contested claim. Critics argue the same research shows tests disproportionately disadvantage low-income and first-generation students. The practical implication is simple: if a school on your list has gone back to test-required, your student needs scores to apply. Check the current policy at the source, not through a third-party article that may be outdated.
How to check any school's current policy
Policies change. Do not rely on articles or search results. Check directly:
- Go to the college's admissions website.
- Search for "testing policy" or "standardized testing."
- Look for the policy labeled for your student's entry year (not last year's admitted class).
- Confirm whether the policy applies to all applicants or only certain programs or residency categories.
Not sure what your student's college list requires?
We will go through the list school by school and tell you exactly what each one needs. English and Spanish. Free 30-minute call.
Book a Free CallFrequently Asked Questions
Is test-optional ending?
No. A small number of highly selective private universities, including MIT, Yale, Dartmouth, Harvard, and Brown, have reverted to test-required policies. The vast majority of colleges remain test-optional. The University of California is permanently test-blind. The CSU system is test-free for admission. More than 80% of four-year colleges in the United States remain test-optional as of 2026. The headline-making reversals affect a narrow slice of highly selective institutions and do not represent a broader trend across American higher education.
What is the difference between test-optional, test-blind, and test-required?
Test-required means the college requires SAT or ACT scores and will not review an application without them. Test-optional means the college will review applications with or without scores, and the student chooses whether to submit. Test-blind (sometimes called test-free) means the college does not look at SAT or ACT scores even if submitted. The University of California is test-blind. Most California community colleges are test-free for admission. Many private and out-of-state colleges are test-optional.
Should a student submit SAT or ACT scores to a test-optional college?
At a test-optional college, submitting scores is advantageous when the student's score is at or above the middle 50% range of admitted students at that school. If the score is below that range, submitting likely hurts rather than helps. Look up each college's published score ranges (usually listed as the 25th and 75th percentile of enrolled students). If the student's score is above the 75th percentile, submit it. If it is below the 25th percentile, do not. If it falls in the middle, it depends on how much other parts of the application compensate.
Why did some colleges go back to test-required?
The colleges that reverted to test-required — MIT, Yale, Dartmouth, Harvard, and a small number of others — cite internal research suggesting that test scores, used alongside other factors, improve their ability to identify high-potential students from disadvantaged backgrounds. Their argument is that test scores provide information that GPA alone does not, particularly in identifying strong students from under-resourced high schools where grade inflation is common. Critics dispute this interpretation. The practical implication for students is straightforward: check each college's current policy and respond accordingly.